Health Digital Check-Up: The Case for Analog
There are many new trends popping up here and there regarding where health communication and care is going thanks to digital technology. That’s NOT what this week’s Health Digital Check-Up is going to cover. Instead, let’s take a look at the opposite side: the places where digital still hasn’t taken hold.
That’s right, the Digital Check-Up is going analog for a week. Shocked? Well here’s five ideas and stories to consider for when it comes to the case for traditional tools in health care. Are these destined to change too?
Word Of Mouth
Online resources may act as a second medical opinion for Internet users, but to find a specialist in the first place, word of mouth may still be number one. Tony Brayer included this point within a guest post at KevinMD: selecting a physician is still very much rooted in referral and less-digital guidance. As he noted, “The primary care physician is still the leading source for patients seeing specialist physicians and the opinions of referring physicians remain the leading factor for an individual patient choosing a hospital.”
Patient-Physician Communication
One of the hot topics of the digital age is how patients and physicians can communicate when they aren’t face-to-face through social networks, e-mail, etc. While the topic is still being discussed, it means that there is an important role of direct communication between physicians and patients. As Stephen Wilkins at Mind the Gap discussed, there are immediate gains from direct, strong communication between a patient and their doctor.
Bookshelves
There always has been a little bit of perceived pride that comes from a hefty bookshelf office, and in the medical industry, perhaps a hearty case of texts and guides will never be replicated by things like e-books and tablets. Think about this quote from Malcolm Jones that appeared in a Newsweek piece on the cultural downside of e-books:
I come from a generation for whom the books and records on the shelf signaled, in some way, who you were (starting with the fact that you were a person who owned books or records or CDs). If you visited a friend, you took the first chance you had to surreptitiously scan that friend’s shelves to get a handle on the person. I suppose I could sneak a peek at a friend’s Kindle, but is that the same? And try that kind of snooping on a bus or in a coffee shop and you’ll probably get arrested.
Rural Practice
For all of the Wi-Fi coffee shops and wired hot spots that fill our major cities, it’s really easy to forget that there are plenty of places around the world that aren’t completely connected. Among other things, practicing medicine and supplying healthcare to these regions relies on traditional, traveling physicians and small practices. Among other challenges to recruiting to this field is a newer one: the impact of the digital age. The attraction for young doctors to join the ranks, as this Washington Post article explained, is fading fast as many new physicians have been trained in a tech-heavy era that may not be as applicable in rural areas.
Nostalgia
Culturally, there may be one thing that never fades: our sense of nostalgia for how things used to be. Perhaps this mindset is one of the greatest challenges of moving forward in the digital space among many healthcare organizations. We have come a long way in the last few decades thanks to technology, but as Paul Waldman wrote last month in The American Prospect, we are in an era of immense innovation, and discussed how nostalgia can actually play into the fears of technological change.













