The Swiss Cheese Web Ain't The Web

April 13th, 2010 View Comments


Edelman Digital Homepage

Seemingly overnight the Information Superhighway (does anyone call it that anymore?) became littered with potholes. In the last week Apple sold nearly 500,000 iPads, none of which support key technologies that we have come to rely on, including Adobe Flash, Windows Media and others. (Adobe and Microsoft are Edelman clients.)

For the last week I have been using my iPad as my primary device. I enjoy the slate format and think it’s the next big thing for computing – one that will see lots of winners. Unfortunately, this comes at a cost. I don’t get to experience the web like I used to, but a version of it that only Apple approves of – one that’s peppered with potholes that turns it into the swiss cheese web. The above image is what our own web site looks like on the iPad, which proudly uses Flash for certain features.

This poses a challenge for Web developers – one that Josh Bernoff so eloquently details on his post on the “Splinternet.” Should one develop the most robust experience using the best technologies on the market or should they kowtow to Apple’s vision for the Internet? Tough call.

In the end we believe that marketers should develop for the masses – the common denominator that unites the broadest universe of consumers. Right now, that’s desktop browsers with plug-ins. However, if developers need to start coding different versions of their site for different platforms, then we have trouble ahead. Standards are what made the web become a mass consumer medium.

Edelman Digital calls on Apple and all companies to support consumer choice – to allow consumers to have the same experience they are accustomed to on the desktop. Where once mobile devices were not powerful enough to run rich media technologies, that’s no longer the case. Why ban Flash and WMVs yet support Quicktime and PDF – two other standards. It makes no sense.

The Swiss Cheese Web ain’t the real web. At minimum Apple and others need to convey this up front (a disclaimer in their ads would be a nice start). However, it is our hope that they will open more and embrace the same standards that have allowed online innovation to blossom.


Steve Rubel
Edelman Digital, New York
Follow on Twitter @steverubel

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,


  • th
    PDF is an open platform.
    Flash is not.

    There is no waffling.

    And why not force the issue of HTML5? HTML5 is also an open standard. It is the future standard of the web.
  • "In the end we believe that marketers should develop for the masses – the common denominator that unites the broadest universe of consumers. "

    I have to disagree only aiming for the middle stifles innovation. Failing to challenge something because that's the way it's done, seems to be the biggest obstacle most businesses have today. Change creates change.

    Is flash really the best tool? From your screen shot the only part or your site that isn't showing is the content rotator at the top of the page and that could be done in php with the same result and not require the viewer have flash installed.

    There is no native WMV support on mac computers either.
  • th, that's certainly an option - but why force this? they appear to be waffling - PDF is ok but Flash isn't.
  • th
    Why not follow the future standard of HTML5 instead?
blog comments powered by Disqus